Shopify Subscriptions: How to Sell Subscriptions in Your Store (Shopify Subscriptions, Recharge, Seal & Co.)

Shopify subscriptions: who they pay off for, what Shopify Subscriptions, Recharge, Seal and Loop cost, and why Shopify Payments and cancellation matter.

Jason Spizert

Jason Spizert

Updated on October 21, 2026

Published 8 min read

The short answer

On Shopify, you sell subscriptions through a subscription app. Shopify Subscriptions is free; alternatives like Seal, Loop or Recharge cost between $0 and $499 per month according to the Shopify App Store, some plus a fee per charge (as of October 21, 2026). Shopify names Shopify Payments as the payment provider for this, others only with restrictions. A subscription only pays off for products that get used up regularly and whose margin covers the discount and shipping per delivery. And if you sell subscriptions online to consumers in Germany, you need a cancellation button under § 312k BGB.

Who is a subscription worth it for in a Shopify store?

For stores with products that get used up and reordered on a fixed rhythm: coffee, pet food, supplements, personal care. There, the subscription takes reordering off the customer's plate. For everything else, a subscription is usually a discount that brings nothing back.

Is a subscription right for your product? Four questions, in this order
01Does your product get used up regularly?If no:No subscription. Here, loyalty comes from new releases, your range and service.
02Do customers reorder at similar intervals?If no:Better to offer bulk packs and a reminder email instead of fixed deliveries.
03Does your margin cover the subscription discount and shipping for every single delivery?If no:Sort out price, package size or rhythm first. Otherwise you lose money on every delivery.
04Do customers forget to reorder without a subscription?If no:Then a subscription mostly gives away discount. A reminder at the right moment may be enough.
Four times yes: offer a subscription, start with a few products and watch cancellations.
A self-check framework, not a guarantee that a subscription will work. Calculate the third question with your own shipping cost per parcel.

Two founders have explained publicly why they don't offer a subscription despite demand. In both cases, it isn't the tech that stops them:

“So why haven't we offered a Duschbrocken subscription yet? It's the logistics costs. […] loyal customers usually don't forget to reorder their Duschbrocken.”
Founder of Duschbrocken, LinkedIn, April 2023 (translated from German)
“everyone needs it, but the intervals are just too irregular. So our loyal customers always stock up themselves 😉 We're going to try bundles.”
Founder of DELINIO (organic olive oil), LinkedIn comment, April 2023 (translated from German)

Remember

A subscription doesn't sell a second product. It takes reordering off the customer's plate. If they never forget to reorder, you're only paying for the discount.

How does a subscription work on Shopify?

The customer picks “Subscribe” on the product page and pays once in the normal Shopify checkout. The subscription app saves this as a subscription contract with rhythm and price. On the due date, it triggers the charge, and according to Shopify's developer docs, a successful charge creates a new order.

How a subscription runs through your storeSign up once, and every delivery after that runs as a completely normal Shopify order.
01Customer picks “Subscribe”One-time purchaseSubscribe, every 4 weeks, with a discount
02Shopify checkoutShopifyApple PayGoogle PayPayPalVisaMastercardThe payment method is stored with Shopify so later deliveries can be charged without a new checkout.
03Subscription appShopify SubscriptionsRechargeSeal SubscriptionsLoopStores the subscription contract with rhythm and price and triggers the charge on schedule.
04Recurring orderCharge successful: Shopify creates a new order. Charge failed: depending on the app, retries and a payment reminder follow.
ShippingDHLDPDLike any other order: label, shipping, tracking.EmailsKlaviyoAnnounce the next delivery, flag a failed payment.Customer accountpauseskipcancelCustomers manage their subscription themselves, without emailing support.
Diagram with examples. Which payment methods work for subscriptions depends on the payment provider; which subscription events reach Klaviyo depends on the app: Recharge, Seal and Loop list Klaviyo as compatible in the App Store. Logos are trademarks of their respective owners.

For you, that means shipping, invoicing and bookkeeping run like any other order. Only three things are new. Customers need a customer account where they manage their subscription themselves, you need emails around the next delivery, and someone has to keep an eye on failed payments.

What can Shopify Subscriptions do, and what does it cost?

Shopify Subscriptions is Shopify's own subscription app and free according to the App Store. It has been around since January 2024 and has 3.7 out of 5 stars from 865 reviews (as of October 21, 2026).

Shopify App Store page of the Shopify Subscriptions app (German interface): pricing free, rating 3.7 from 865 reviews, developer Shopify
Screenshot: Shopify App Store, Shopify Subscriptions, October 21, 2026.
What the free app can do and where it stops
CanSubscription discount, fixed or custom prices, automatic recurring billing, pause, skip and cancel in the customer account, custom email templates, reports, import of existing subscription contracts.
Can'tBundles in subscriptions, subscriptions via draft orders and later order edits via the API. Gift cards only apply to the first payment.
Per the Shopify App Store and the Shopify Help Center on the app, retrieved October 21, 2026. Requirement: a theme with sections and blocks.

The app itself costs nothing, but payments do: your plan's fees apply. What those are is covered in How much does Shopify cost? According to the Shopify Help Center, additional fees may apply depending on your setup.

Recharge, Seal, Loop: what do the alternatives cost?

The alternatives cost between $0 and $499 per month, and some also take a share of every charge. In return, they bring more: bundles in subscriptions, custom cancellation flows with a retention offer, recovery of failed payments and ready-made Klaviyo integrations.

AppPrice per month per App StoreFee per chargeRatingApp language
Shopify Subscriptionsfreeno app fee3.7 (865)incl. German
Seal Subscriptions$0 up to 50 subscriptions, $5.95 up to 100, $9.95 up to 250, $24.95 up to 5000%4.9 (3,147)incl. German
Loop$0 up to 50 active subscriptions, Starter $99, Pro $399Starter 1.0%, Pro 0.75%5.0 (789)English
Recharge$25 (first 50 subscribers without fee), Starter $99, Plus $499Starter 1.49% + $0.19, Plus 1.34% + $0.194.8 (3,140)English

A sample calculation shows what that means per month. Percentages look small, but they grow with every subscription:

Monthly app costs at 300 subscriptions of $30 each ($9,000 subscription revenue)
Shopify Subscriptionsfree$0no app fee
Seal SubscriptionsLegend, up to 500 subscriptions$24.95$24.95 flat, 0% per charge
LoopStarter$189$99 + 1.0% of $9,000
RechargeStarter$290.10$99 + 1.49% of $9,000 + 300 × $0.19
Sample calculation with prices from the Shopify App Store, retrieved October 21, 2026, billed in USD. Assumption: one charge per subscription per month. The payment fees of your Shopify plan apply on top for all four. The apps differ in features; price alone doesn't decide.

Start with the app that solves today's problem, not the one that fits in three years. How to choose apps in general and get rid of them again is covered in Shopify apps: which ones your store really needs. Moving later is possible: according to the App Store, Shopify Subscriptions imports existing subscription contracts.

Do you need Shopify Payments for subscriptions?

Usually yes. The general Shopify Help Center article on payments says that if you sell subscription products, you need Shopify Payments as your main payment provider. The help page on subscription products also lists PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen and Stripe, the last two with restrictions.

Which payment paths support subscriptions works limited unlikely
Shopify PaymentsPaymentsApple PayGoogle PayPayPalVisaMastercardThe intended main path. Customers can subscribe with card, Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay or PayPal, in some stores only with Shop Pay. Apple Pay for subscriptions only with Visa and Mastercard.
PayPal ExpressPayPalPossible as a wallet. Without Shopify Payments active, Shopify charges its additional fee on these payments.
Adyen, Stripe, Authorize.netAdyen only with existing Adyen approval, Stripe only for selected merchants, Authorize.net only with PayPal as a wallet.
Bank transfer and other manual or local payment methodsAccording to Shopify, possibly not available for subscriptions. Don't assume every payment method in your checkout will also appear for subscriptions.
Source: Shopify Help Center on subscription products and the Shopify Subscriptions app, retrieved October 21, 2026. According to Shopify, which payment providers are available in your country depends on the region and the provider's terms.

Important: subscription customers mainly pay by card and wallets. Payment methods that work in your normal checkout don't automatically show up for subscriptions. Check this before launch with a real test order.

Selling to consumers in Germany: cancellation button and contract terms

If you sell subscriptions to consumers in Germany, two rules from the German Civil Code (BGB) affect almost every product subscription. This is information on the legal situation, not legal advice; for your terms and subscription flow, ask a lawyer specializing in IT law.

The cancellation button is set out in § 312k BGB. It has applied since July 1, 2022, including to contracts concluded before that date (Art. 229 § 60 EGBGB). It covers contracts that consumers can conclude on a website and that create an ongoing paid service. In short: a clearly labeled button (“Verträge hier kündigen”, cancel contracts here) that is always available, a confirmation page asking who is canceling which contract and as of when, a second button (“jetzt kündigen”, cancel now) and an immediate confirmation to the customer in text form. If it's missing, customers can cancel such a contract at any time without notice (§ 312k (6) BGB). Check before launch whether the cancellation in your subscription app's customer account meets these requirements.

For contract terms, § 309 no. 9 BGB applies to contracts from March 1, 2022, and covers clauses in your terms: an initial term of at most two years, tacit renewal only for an indefinite period with at most one month's notice, and a notice period of at most one month before the end of the initial term. Many store subscriptions can be canceled at any time without a minimum term, so these limits hardly apply.

How can you tell if your subscription is working?

By the cancellation rate, not by the number of new subscriptions. A subscription canceled after the second delivery has mostly cost you discount. Four metrics are enough to start:

Four metrics that show a subscription honestly
Subscription shareorders from subscriptionsall ordersWhat share of your orders is already recurring?
Cancellation rate (churn)cancellations in the monthactive subscriptions at the start of the monthHow fast are you losing subscribers again?
Failed chargesfailed chargesall charge attemptsHow many subscriptions end quietly, without anyone canceling?
Deliveries per subscriptionsuccessful deliveriesended subscriptionsHow long does a subscriber stay on average?
Deliberately without benchmarks. Compare your subscription with its own previous months, not with numbers from other industries.

With the cancellation rate and the cart value, you can calculate what a subscriber is worth over their lifetime. The formula is in How to calculate customer lifetime value, in the section on subscription models.

Edip from NextPercent going through printed designs at a table
Before choosing an app, do the math: reorder rhythm, margin, shipping per delivery.

Most cancellations happen between two deliveries, which is exactly where emails do their work: announcing the next delivery, suggesting a skip instead of a cancellation, a reminder after a failed payment. How we set up these flows in Klaviyo is on Shopify email marketing.

Launch a subscription if …

  • your product gets used up regularly
  • your margin covers the discount and shipping per delivery
  • you use Shopify Payments or can use it
  • cancellation and the customer account are tested before launch

Wait if …

  • customers reorder at very different intervals
  • your regulars reliably reorder anyway
  • nobody is handling cancellations and failed payments yet

Who this doesn't apply to: fashion, furniture, gifts. There, loyalty comes from your brand and your range. If you want to know where your store is losing buyers today, book the free call below.

Frequently asked questions

Yes, with a subscription app. Shopify has its own free app, Shopify Subscriptions. There are also apps like Recharge, Seal Subscriptions or Loop with more features and their own fees.

According to the Shopify App Store, the app is free (as of October 21, 2026). The normal payment fees of your Shopify plan apply, and according to the Shopify Help Center, additional fees may apply depending on your setup.

Usually yes. The Shopify Help Center names Shopify Payments as the main payment provider for subscription products. PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen and Stripe are also supported, but the last two only with approval or for selected merchants.

For a test with a few products, Shopify Subscriptions is often enough because it's free. If you need bundles in subscriptions, custom cancellation flows or deep Klaviyo integration, look at Seal, Loop or Recharge. Run the fees with your own number of subscriptions.

If you sell to consumers in Germany and they can sign up on your website, § 312k of the German Civil Code (BGB) has required a cancellation button with a confirmation page since July 1, 2022. If it's missing, customers can cancel at any time without notice. This is information, not legal advice.

Products that get used up regularly and are reordered at similar intervals, such as coffee, pet food, supplements or personal care products. It also matters that your margin covers the subscription discount and the shipping of every single delivery.

See all insights

  • Reply within 24 hours
  • No obligation, no sales pitch

Request an intro call

How can we help?*
What budget do you have in mind?*

By submitting, you agree to the processing of your data as described in our privacy policy.

Rather pick a time directly?

Book a call directly
Patricia from the NextPercent team working on a laptop in an armchair

Jennifer Rosbach

Beauty brand (nagelati.de)

“As a young brand, it mattered to us to work with a partner who doesn't just execute, but really understands how ecommerce brands grow. That's exactly what we found. Clear communication, honest assessments and a good feel for conversion and brand presence.”