How to Calculate CAC: What a New Customer Really Costs Your Store

Calculate CAC: the formula, which costs belong in it, blended vs. channel CAC, finding new customers in Shopify and a calculator. Example: €40 turns into €56.

Jason Spizert

Jason Spizert

Updated on October 21, 2026

Published 7 min read

The short answer

Here is how you calculate CAC (customer acquisition cost): all costs of acquiring new customers in a period divided by the number of new customers in the same period. Costs include ads across all channels, agency, creators, new customer discounts and prorated tools. You count new customers in Shopify, not in the ad account. Example: €5,600 in costs and 100 new customers make €56 per new customer.

How do you calculate CAC?

With one division: cost of acquiring new customers divided by new customers, both from the same period. The formula is simple. The hard part is the two numbers you put into it.

"Now you: what does a new customer cost you?"
Founder of a D2C brand, LinkedIn (translated from German)

An example. Kanto sells e-bike accessories. In October, the store spends €4,000 on ads, plus agency, creators, discounts and tools. Shopify counts 100 new customers. The costs sit in six accounts, the new customers in only one place:

Where the numbers for CAC come fromThe costs sit in many accounts. The new customers sit in only one place: your store.
Costs for the month, from every accountTotal €5,600
MetaMeta€2,800Google AdsGoogle Ads€900TikTokTikTok€300InstagramCreators€500ShopifyDiscounts€360Agency, tools€740
CAC calculation€5,600 ÷ 100 new customers = €56Counting ads only, it would be €40.
Shopify"New vs. returning customers" report: 100 first-time customers this month100
Example calculation with the sample store Kanto, one month. Costs from the ad accounts, invoices and the discount report; new customers from Shopify. Logos are trademarks of their respective owners.

If Kanto counts only ads, the CAC comes out at €40. With all costs, it is €56, which is 40 percent more. That is not a rounding error. It is the question of whether a new customer makes money or costs money.

Kanto, one month: what is in the costs
Ads €4,000Other costs €1,600
Meta€2,800Google Ads€900TikTok€300Agency, freelancers€600Creators€500New customer discounts€360Tools, prorated€140
Ads only€4,000 ÷ 100 = €40All costs of acquiring new customers€5,600 ÷ 100 = €56
Example calculation, no client data. Discounts for new customers count as costs here. If you already deduct them from the order value, they do not belong in CAC a second time.

Which costs belong in CAC?

Everything you spend so that someone buys for the first time. What you spend on existing customers, or what every order costs anyway, stays out. The line is not always sharp, so one thing matters most: you calculate the same way every month.

ItemIn CAC?Why
Ad spend, all channelsYesMeta, Google Ads, TikTok, Pinterest: everything in the same month, net.
Agency, freelancersYes, proratedOnly the part that works on new customers. Not the upkeep of emails to regular customers.
Creators, influencersYesFees, commission and the purchase cost of gifted products.
Discounts for new customersYes, or in the contribution marginWelcome codes cost money. But count them in one place only, never twice.
Advertising toolsProratedCreative tools, tracking, landing page builders.
In-house marketing teamFor full CACIf you include salaries, you see the real costs. What matters is doing it the same way every time.
Product cost, shipping, payment feesNoThese apply to every order and are part of the contribution margin.
Emails and loyalty program for regular customersNoThose are retention costs, not acquisition costs.

Discounts are where the most common double-counting happens. According to its own help center, Shopify calculates average order value after discounts. If you build your contribution margin on that value, the discount is already included there and does not belong in CAC a second time.

"If you burn your margin in fulfillment, you have nothing left to fight back with in marketing."
E-commerce practitioner with food D2C experience, LinkedIn (translated from German)

What the ads themselves cost and what drives the price per purchase is covered in the article How much do Instagram and Facebook ads cost?

Blended CAC or channel CAC: which one is right?

Both, for different questions. Blended CAC divides all costs by all new customers. It shows whether your business holds up, and it cannot count anything twice. Channel CAC divides a channel's costs by that channel's new customers. It shows where the next euro should go.

The same month, two perspectivesChannel CAC: a channel's ad costs divided by the new customers Shopify attributes to that channel.
Google Ads · €900 ÷ 30 new customers€30.00
Meta · €2,800 ÷ 60 new customers€46.67
TikTok · €300 ÷ 4 new customers€75.00
Marker: blended CAC from ads, €4,000 ÷ 100 new customers = €40
Blended CACAll costs divided by all new customers. Shows whether the business holds up. Cannot count anything twice.Channel CACShows where the next euro should go. Depends on the attribution model and is therefore less precise.
Example calculation. 30 + 60 + 4 = 94 new customers came through paid channels, 6 without ads (direct, search, referral). They are in the blended CAC, but in no channel CAC.

The catch with channel CAC is attribution. According to its help center, Shopify offers several models: first click, last click, last non-direct click and any click. With the "any click" model, every channel involved gets credited with the full order, so the total is larger than the number of orders. Why Meta, GA4 and Shopify show different numbers anyway is explained in the article Shopify, GA4 and Meta show different numbers.

Rule of thumb for steering

Whether you make money is decided by blended CAC. Where the budget goes is decided by channel CAC. You need both, but not for the same question.

Where do you find your new customers in Shopify?

In the "New vs. returning customers" report. There, Shopify counts first-time customers separately from returning ones for each period. According to Shopify, a first-time customer is someone who placed their first order in your store.

Four steps to your number of new customers
Open reportsIn the Shopify admin: Analytics, Reports, filter by category, "Customers".
New vs. returning customersGroup by month. The "First-time" row is your denominator.
Keep the period the sameCosts and new customers from the same month. Always pull the number at the same point in time, for example at month end.
For channel CAC: cohortsCustomer cohort analysis, cohort definition, filter "First order" by marketing channel.
Menu paths and report names per the Shopify Help Center "Customer reports", accessed October 21, 2026.
Excerpt from the German Shopify help center on the New vs. returning customers report: the report shows the number of first-time and returning customers for a period, groupable from hour to calendar month, with one row for each customer type
Screenshot: Shopify Help Center (German version), Customer reports, October 21, 2026. The first-time customers row is the denominator of your CAC calculation.

The same help page contains a trap: customer reports use the entire order history. Someone who buys for the first time in November and again in December shows up as returning in a November report, according to Shopify. If you look up old months later, the numbers may have shifted. So always record your new customers at the same point in time.

For channel CAC, the customer cohort analysis helps. There, you filter the first order by marketing channel and see how many new customers a channel brought in.

Which mistakes make CAC look too good?

Two mistakes that push in the same direction: the numerator is too small or the denominator too large. Both lower CAC, and neither stands out, because the number looks good. At Kanto, the same data produces four values between €31 and €56.

One month at Kanto, four CAC values
Meta costs ÷ purchases per Meta€31.11
€2,800 ÷ 90 · Only one account, existing customers included
All costs ÷ all orders€32.00
€5,600 ÷ 175 · Regular customers push the number down
Ads only ÷ new customers€40.00
€4,000 ÷ 100 · Agency, creators, discounts missing
All costs ÷ new customers€56.00
€5,600 ÷ 100 · The real CAC
Marker: €51.20 contribution margin per customer in 12 months (CLV)
Example calculation. Three calculations sit below the marker and look profitable. Only the fourth shows that Kanto loses money on every new customer in the first year.
Edip from NextPercent going through printed drafts at a table
First the cost list, then the division. If you write down every item once, you calculate the same way every month.

Counting existing customers. If you divide by all orders, you get the regular-customer bonus for free: they buy anyway and push the number down. At Kanto, CAC drops from €56 to €32 this way. Looking at only one ad account. Cost per purchase in Meta Ads Manager includes neither Google nor creators, and Meta counts purchases by its own attribution. How Meta, Google and Shopify calculate is shown in the article How to calculate ROAS.

"Customer acquisition costs and marketing costs in general were still much lower, which meant our margin was higher."
Co-founder of a jewelry brand, LinkedIn (translated from German)

When has a new customer paid for themselves?

When their contribution margin overtakes CAC. Divide CAC by the contribution margin per order and you know how often a new customer has to buy. At Kanto, one order brings in €32.

How many orders a new customer needs to pay backCAC divided by €32 contribution margin per order. Kanto customers reach 1.6 in 12 months.
€40 CAC: paid back in the fourth month1.25 orders are within the 1.6 that Kanto customers reach in their first year.€56 CAC: not paid back after 12 months1.75 orders would be needed. That is 0.15 orders short, or €4.80 per customer.
Example calculation. How orders build up month by month is shown in the article on customer lifetime value. The shaded area shows how far Kanto customers get on average after 12 months.

With a €40 CAC, Kanto looked profitable. With €56, the store does not earn the costs back even in the first year. How a customer's value grows over 12 months and which CLV to CAC ratio makes sense is covered in the article How to calculate customer lifetime value. Run it with your numbers:

What does a new customer cost you?
Nothing is stored or sent.
€
Meta, Google Ads, TikTok and all other ad accounts in the same month, net.
€
Only the part that works on acquiring new customers.
€
Fees, commissions and the purchase cost of gifted products.
€
Only if you do not already deduct them in the contribution margin.
€
customers
First-time customers per Shopify, not all orders.
€
Order value minus product cost, shipping, payment fees and returns.
€
How to calculate it is explained in the article on customer lifetime value.
CAC, ads only
€40.00
The number most people calculate. Too low.
CAC, all costs
€56.00
The number you plan budgets with.
Orders to pay back
1.75
How often a new customer has to buy to pay for their acquisition.
CLV to CAC
0.9 : 1
Below 1 : 1 you lose money on the customer, even over 12 months.
With all costs, your CAC is €56.00, 40 percent above the ads-only CAC. Even after 12 months, you are €4.80 short per new customer. Then you cut costs, raise the contribution margin or win more repeat purchases.

If your CAC is above your CLV, there are three levers: cut costs, raise the contribution margin per order or win more repeat purchases. Where the budget can be steered, take a look at our approach to performance marketing. Where visitors drop off before their first purchase, the lever is conversion optimization.

When is this calculation not enough?

When the numbers are too small or new customers do not end up in your store.

Calculating monthly is enough if …

  • you have enough new customers every month that one more or less does not tip the number.
  • your costs fall in the same month in which they take effect.
  • almost all orders go through your Shopify store.
  • you keep the cost list the same way every month.

Calculate differently if …

  • you only have a handful of new customers a month. Then calculate per quarter.
  • a big creator deal or a trade show falls in one month but works over several. Then spread the costs.
  • many customers buy via Amazon or retail. They do not show up in Shopify as new customers.
  • you sell a subscription. Then what counts is how long customers stay, not just the first order.

Whether your store is already losing customers before the ads even matter is what our conversion optimization finds out.

Key takeaway

CAC is not what your ad account shows per purchase. It is everything you spend on a new customer, divided by the new customers Shopify counts.

Frequently asked questions

Divide all costs you spend in a period on acquiring new customers by the number of new customers in the same period. €5,600 in costs and 100 new customers give you a CAC of €56.

Ad spend across all channels, the share of agency or freelancer work that wins new customers, creator fees and gifted products, discounts for new customers and prorated tools. Product cost, shipping and payment fees do not belong in it; they are part of the contribution margin.

Blended CAC divides all costs by all new customers and shows whether your business holds up. Channel CAC divides a channel's costs by the new customers attributed to that channel. It helps you allocate budget, but depends on the attribution model.

Under Analytics, Reports, category Customers, in the "New vs. returning customers" report. It shows first-time customers separately from returning ones for each period.

No. Meta only divides Meta's costs by the purchases Meta attributes to itself, existing customers included. CAC takes all costs and divides by the new customers from your store.

When it is higher than the contribution margin a customer brings you in 12 months. If it is above the contribution margin of the first order but below that, you front money and earn it back through repeat purchases.

Monthly, if you have enough new customers that individual outliers do not tip the number. With only a few new customers a month, you are better off calculating per quarter.

See all insights

  • Reply within 24 hours
  • No obligation, no sales pitch

Request an intro call

How can we help?*
What budget do you have in mind?*

By submitting, you agree to the processing of your data as described in our privacy policy.

Rather pick a time directly?

Book a call directly
Patricia from the NextPercent team working on a laptop in an armchair

Jennifer Rosbach

Beauty brand (nagelati.de)

“As a young brand, it mattered to us to work with a partner who doesn't just execute, but really understands how ecommerce brands grow. That's exactly what we found. Clear communication, honest assessments and a good feel for conversion and brand presence.”