How to Find Influencers: The Right Creators for Your Online Store (Without an Agency Database)

How to find, vet and approach the right influencers for your online store, choose commission or a flat fee, and measure in Shopify who actually sells.

Jason Spizert

Jason Spizert

Updated on October 21, 2026

Published 8 min read

The short answer

You can find the right influencers without an agency database in four places: among your own customers, via search and hashtags on Instagram and TikTok, in the creator marketplaces of Meta and TikTok, and in the Shopify app Collabs. More important than finding them is vetting: genuine comments, an audience that fits your store and a style that fits your brand. Then give every creator their own discount code or link in Shopify. The “Sales by discount code” report then shows you who actually sells.

Why small creators often fit better than big names

When people look for influencers, they usually look for reach first. For a store, something else matters: how many people in the audience have exactly the problem your product solves?

Fit over reachWhat matters isn't how many people watch. It's how many of them need your product.
Big nameBroad audience. Few of them fit your store.
Small creator from your nicheSmall audience. Many of them have exactly your problem.
fits your productjust watchesA diagram, not a measurement. The thesis behind it: small niche creators are believed more readily than a famous face everyone assumes is paid. Whether it holds for your product only your own discount code will show.

Our thesis, from running creator programs: audiences immediately assume a famous face is being paid. A small creator who genuinely uses the product is more likely to be believed. They're also willing to deliver content on an ongoing basis rather than a single post. In the end, only your own code can prove it.

Remember

You're not looking for reach. You're looking for people whose audience has your problem.

There's one exception: if you need to make a new category known, a big name can buy attention. That doesn't guarantee sales.

Where do you find the right influencers?

In four places, and the first two cost nothing: among your customers, in Instagram and TikTok search, in the Meta and TikTok marketplaces and in Shopify Collabs. The whole path to reporting looks like this:

From search to reportingFinding is the smallest part. Whether a creator sells you only see once each one has their own code and link in Shopify.
Where to search
InstagramSearch, hashtagsTikTokSearch, TikTok OneMetaCreator hubShopify CollabsCollabsYour customers
VetGenuine comments, a matching audience, a style that fits the brand
Reach outA personal message with a clear offer and clear expectations
ShopifyOwn discount code and shareable link per creator
Sales by discount codeShopify report: revenue per code
Sales by referrer URLShopify report: where buyers came from
CommissionCollabs or an affiliate app settles it
Diagram, not a product comparison. Features per the help pages of Instagram, TikTok, Meta and Shopify (retrieved October 21, 2026). Logos are trademarks of their respective owners.
Where to searchWhat you find thereAccessCatch
Your customersTags of your store, reviews with photos, replies to your emailsImmediate, freeOnly a few have an audience
Instagram: search and hashtagsHashtag and location pages with all public posts on themFree in the appPrivate accounts missing, lots of manual work
TikTok: searchPeople, posts, sounds and hashtags, with filters to narrow downFree in the appNo audience data
Meta creator marketing hubRecommendations, keyword search, filters by interests, age, follower count and audienceMeta Business Suite, verified business portfolioDetailed insights only for creators in the Creator Marketplace (from 1,000 followers)
TikTok OneFilters by country, follower count, language, audience, median views and engagement rateTikTok One account, creator data separated by regionCreators 18+, for projects from 1,000 followers
Shopify CollabsSearch by keyword, location, platform and audience sizeFree to install, not on the Starter and Retail plansNot accepting new creators at the moment

Start with your customers. Someone who has already bought your product and posts about it doesn't have to act. Look at who tags your store, and ask for photos in your shipping email. A good foundation for this is customer retention: people who like coming back also like recommending.

Then hashtags and search. On Instagram, every hashtag page shows all public posts with that hashtag. Don't search for your product name, but for your customers' everyday life: #commuting instead of #ebike. On TikTok, you narrow the results with filters.

For more speed, the marketplaces. In the creator marketing hub, you filter by interests, age, follower count and audience, see past Partnership Ads and can message creators directly. Whether it's enabled for your brand you can see in Meta Business Suite under creator marketing.

Excerpt from the Instagram Help Center (German version), article on finding creators for partnerships in the Meta creator marketing hub: Discover creators tab, AI-powered keyword search, filters by interests, age and follower count, filters by audience
Screenshot: Instagram Help Center (German version), finding creators in the Meta creator marketing hub, October 21, 2026.

How do you check whether an influencer fits your store?

With three questions: is the engagement real, does the audience fit, does the style fit? The follower count answers none of them. The comments answer the first, an Insights screenshot the second, three recent videos the third.

Three questions before every outreach
01Is the engagement real?
Read the comments: full sentences and questions about the product, not just emojisCompare several posts, not the one outlierDoes the creator reply in the comments?
02Does the audience fit?
Ask for an Insights screenshot: countries, cities, age, genderA 30- or 90-day period, not just the last 7Is the audience where you ship?
03Does the style fit the brand?
Shows products in use, not just held up to the cameraThe first seconds grab you, sound and light are rightPast collaborations clearly labeled as advertising
Red flagsasks for free products firsthardly any comments despite many followersno numbers when askedcollaborations without disclosure
According to its own help center, Instagram only shows demographic data once an account has reached or engaged more than 100 accounts. If it's missing, the account is still too small to vet.
“In the end, none of them got anything, because on closer inspection they were often brand-new channels without any meaningful followers, and the self-proclaimed stars were just keen on free products.”
Store owner, sellerforum.de (translated from German)

Feel free to ask for the Insights screenshot. For the accounts they've reached, Instagram shows creators the top countries, cities and age groups as well as the gender split. Anyone working professionally sends it in a minute.

Three people from the NextPercent team at a wooden table, one pointing with a pen at a tablet
Go through candidates together: comments, insights, the last three videos. Only then write.

How do you approach creators so they reply?

Personally, specifically and with a clear offer. A message that obviously went to a hundred accounts rarely gets a reply.

“After ~4 weeks on Shopify Collabs, and a total of 429 total custom emails (probably 30+ hours of time) I've received a total of ~2 or maybe 3 responses.”
Merchant, Shopify Community

Lots of emails don't replace selection. Better to write to ten creators whose videos you've actually watched than to three hundred from a list. This is how an outreach message that gets answered is built:

An outreach message that gets answered
Hey, your reel about commuting in the rain stuck with me. That's exactly how our customers ride.01A specific reference to a video
We're Kanto, we build e-bikes for everyday city life.02Who you are, in one sentence
We'd send you a bike, plus your own code with 10% off for your followers and commission on every purchase with it.03A clear offer
In return: three videos in the first month, labeled as advertising.04A clear expectation
Would you have 15 minutes for a quick chat next week?05A small next step
Example brand Kanto; discount and scope are placeholders. What you offer depends on your margin.

Expectations and disclosure belong in the first message, not a later one. Anyone who agrees after that knows what they're getting into. Anyone who only wants free products usually drops out at this point.

Commission or flat fee: how do you pay influencers?

With commission, as soon as a creator posts themselves and brings buyers via code or link. Then they only earn when something sells and have the same incentive as you. A flat fee fits when you're buying videos you run as ads yourself.

Who carries the risk if nothing sells?
Flat feeYou carry the riskFits when: The creator delivers videos you run as ads yourself.Catch: You pay even if the post doesn't sell anything.
Flat fee or commissionSharedFits when: At the start, when the creator doesn't trust your brand yet.Catch: Only against a fixed number of videos per month. Once the commission carries itself, the flat fee goes away.
CommissionThe creator carries itFits when: The creator posts themselves and brings buyers via code or link.Catch: If you also run the same video as an ad, you pay for the customer twice.
The model in the middle (“whichever is higher, flat fee or commission”) comes from running creator programs, not from a study. We deliberately don't name rates: what you can pay follows from your margin and repeat purchases.

One mistake is especially costly: commission and ad budget for the same video. Then you pay for the same customer twice, once to Meta and once to the creator. What a purchase via ads can cost is calculated in How much do Instagram and Facebook ads cost?

How much commission you can afford depends less on the first purchase than on a customer's value over time. If they buy again, the margin carries more. How to calculate that is in How to calculate customer lifetime value. Market prices for individual videos are in our article on UGC content.

Selling in Germany: does an influencer have to label ads?

In Germany, yes, as soon as they receive consideration for the post: money, commission or a product tied to a post. In 2021, the German Federal Court of Justice ruled that a post made in return for consideration must be recognizable as advertising (judgment of September 9, 2021, I ZR 90/20). Today this is stated explicitly in § 5a (4) of the German Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG), which even presumes consideration.

How to disclose in Germany, per the guidelines of the German media authorities
Paid post“Werbung” or “Anzeige” (advertisement) at the start, easy to read
Product gifted, post expectedThe same. The product counts as consideration
Discount code in the post“Werbung” or “Anzeige” right next to the code
Affiliate linkAn asterisk (*) and an explanation right at the link
Enough“Werbung”, “Anzeige” or the platform label “paid partnership”Not enough“ad”, “sponsored by”, “PR sample”, “advertorial”
Simplified from the guideline “Werbekennzeichnung bei Online-Medien” by the German media authorities (Die Medienanstalten), as of May 2025. Not legal advice.

For you as a store, that means: write the disclosure into the agreement and look at the first posts. If a creator posts without a label, address it right away. This section isn't legal advice. For your agreement, ask a lawyer specializing in media and IT law.

How do you measure in Shopify which creator sells?

With a separate discount code and a separate link for each creator. In Shopify, you create the code under Discounts and get a shareable link via “Promote”. It applies the discount automatically and can lead straight to a product page. The “Sales by discount code” report then shows what was sold via each code. “Total sales by referrer URL” shows which site buyers came from.

“Right now I've just handled it with a discount and then always written down the history so I can pay out the correct commission each quarter. But I don't think that's the ideal solution.”
Brand working with athletes, Shopify Community (translated from German)

Shopify Collabs takes the note-taking off your hands. Shopify's free app manages codes, links, gifts and commission and pays out via your Shopify bill. Since it isn't accepting new creators at the moment, it's mainly a tool for creators you invite yourself. Within seven days, you can invite up to 100 creators.

Excerpt from the Shopify App Store (German interface), Shopify Collabs app: pricing free to install, rating 4.2 from 439 reviews, developer Shopify, features such as application page, open access program, gifts and automatic commissions
Screenshot: Shopify App Store, Shopify Collabs, October 21, 2026.
Only pay commission once the purchase is final
Day 0Purchase with code or linkShopify attributes the order to the creator.
+ 14 daysWithdrawal periodFor goods, it runs from receipt. Until then, the order can come back (in Germany: §§ 355, 356 BGB).
30 daysHolding period in CollabsDefault, adjustable from 1 to 90 days.
thenPayoutVia your Shopify bill to the creator, by PayPal or bank transfer.
Holding period, billing and payout per the Shopify Help Center on Collabs, retrieved October 21, 2026. A 2.9% processing fee applies there to every automatic commission payment.

Collabs isn't the only option. Other affiliate apps do the same, often with more settings. What to look for in apps is covered in Shopify apps: which ones your store really needs. If you also want to run the best creator videos as ads, our Meta Ads agency can help.

Influencers are worth it if …

  • your product has a visible moment: unboxing, use, before and after.
  • your margin supports the discount and commission.
  • your store already turns visitors into buyers.

Not yet if …

  • visitors come but don't buy. Then every creator click fizzles out too.
  • nothing is left after discount and commission.
  • nobody looks after the creators, answers their questions and checks the payouts.

Where visitors drop off after the click is covered in Shopify traffic but no sales. Or let us show you on a free call.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

Start with your customers, then search via hashtags and search on Instagram and TikTok. If you need more filters, use Meta's creator marketing hub or TikTok One. Then check comments, audience and style before you reach out to anyone.

Yes. Search and hashtag pages on Instagram and TikTok cost nothing, and neither do your own customers. Shopify Collabs is free to install; fees only apply on commission.

Creators with a smaller, usually very topic-focused audience. There is no fixed threshold; platforms and agencies draw the line differently. For a store, the follower count matters less than whether the audience fits your product.

Read the comments across several posts: real followers ask questions and write full sentences. Also ask for a screenshot of their Instagram Insights with countries, cities and age groups.

As a tool for codes, links, gifts and commission, yes, on all plans except Starter and Retail. According to Shopify, however, Collabs isn't accepting new creators at the moment, and only creators from the US, the UK and Canada can join the open program. You invite your own creators directly.

In Germany, usually yes, if a post is expected: according to the guideline of the German media authorities, the product then counts as consideration. The exception is a product in a minor role worth up to €100. For your case, ask a lawyer specializing in media and IT law.

That depends on the model: a flat fee for videos, commission on sales via code or link, or a mix. What's common and what individual videos cost is in our article on UGC content. What you can pay follows from your margin.

See all insights

  • Reply within 24 hours
  • No obligation, no sales pitch

Request an intro call

How can we help?*
What budget do you have in mind?*

By submitting, you agree to the processing of your data as described in our privacy policy.

Rather pick a time directly?

Book a call directly
Patricia from the NextPercent team working on a laptop in an armchair

Jennifer Rosbach

Beauty brand (nagelati.de)

“As a young brand, it mattered to us to work with a partner who doesn't just execute, but really understands how ecommerce brands grow. That's exactly what we found. Clear communication, honest assessments and a good feel for conversion and brand presence.”